Related: 9 Foods That (Almost) Never Go Bad Commercially made peanut butter, like Jif or Skippy, does well in a pantry because it's out of direct sunlight and remains relatively cool and dry.

Wegmans' peanut butter was tasty and notably denser than the others I tried. Its texture reminded me of Jif peanut butter because it was thick and a little less creamy than I prefer. Still ...

I let her know I’d baked her Jif jar peanut butter cookie recipe ... substitutes “biscuit baking mix” for flour. I’ve had bad ...

Our favorite is Jif Creamy, but use whatever you have. We do suggest leaving out the natural kinds, however. Natural peanut butter may well lead to crumbly peanut butter balls that don't retain ...